When do you need a Direct audit?
An audit is not scheduled maintenance. It is done when the ads raise a question that has no answer in numbers. The usual reasons:
- The budget is being spent, and neither you nor the agency knows what a lead costs.
- The agency “runs the campaigns”, and the report is a screenshot without a single decision.
- You are changing agencies or taking over the account from an employee who left. You need to understand what you have inherited.
- You are about to raise the budget. Scale what pays off, not everything at once.
- The cost per lead jumped, although “nothing was changed” in the settings.
- There are clicks, but no leads, or the wrong people come.
There is a caveat with the last point. Leads are often lost not in the ads but on the site or in the sales team. First walk the customer’s path yourself — how to do that is covered in the article “Clicks but no leads”. If everything is fine there, the next step is a campaign audit.
When it’s too early for an audit: the campaign has just launched and there is almost no data. Any conclusion from the first clicks is guesswork. First you need a volume at which anything can be said at all.
Where does an audit start — with the ads or with the analytics?
With the analytics. If leads aren’t counted, there is nothing to judge the campaigns by. Any optimization is then done blind, and the Direct strategy learns from whatever it was shown.
What is checked:
- Metrica counter. Is it installed on all landing pages, and is it specified in the campaign settings.
- Goals. Are there goals that equal a lead: a form submission, a call, a messenger message. A “viewed several pages” goal is not a lead.
- Duplicate conversions. Direct Help gives a direct example: if the goal is set to the “Thank you for your purchase” page and the person comes back to it, the goal is counted again — and antifraud won’t filter that out (Help). The cost per lead in the report is then understated.
- The yclid tag. Direct adds it to ad links itself, and Metrica uses it to link a visit to a specific click. If the site has a redirect, the tag can get lost. Help asks you to check that it reaches the final URL (Help).
- Attribution model. To monitor a conversion strategy, you need to select the same model in the report as in the strategy settings (Help). Otherwise the cost per lead in the report and the one the strategy is aiming for are different numbers, and arguing about them is pointless.
A common separate question is why Direct clicks and Metrica visits don’t match. This is normal, and the gap by itself is no cause for alarm. Details are in the article on different numbers in Direct and Metrica.
What is checked in the campaigns themselves?
Next — where the money goes. We go from the most expensive mistakes to the cosmetic ones.
Search queries. Not the key phrases you set, but the actual searches your ads were shown for. The “Search queries” report shows for each one what triggered the impression — a key phrase or autotargeting — and the match type: word-for-word or semantic, with synonyms and rephrasings (Help). The gap between your list of words and this report is a common source of wasted spend. Where it comes from is covered in the article on unrelated searches in Direct.
Autotargeting. It selects impressions without key phrases — based on the ad text and the landing page — and works alongside phrases with equal priority (Help). On search it has categories: target, narrow, broad, alternative and related searches, plus searches mentioning brands. The audit checks which categories are on and what a lead costs in each.
Network placements. Campaigns in the Yandex Advertising Network have a “Placements” report. From it you can also block impressions on specific sites and apps (Help). At the same time, Help advises making decisions on statistically significant data. That is, not switching off a placement because of one expensive day.
Negative phrases. Are there any at all. Do they overlap with key phrases. At what level are they set — ad group or campaign.
Strategy and goal. Which strategy is selected and which goal it learns on. If a campaign optimizes for visits or for a goal that does not equal a lead, it will honestly bring what it was asked for. Only those won’t be customers.
Geography and time. Do they match where and when you can actually serve a customer.
Ads and landing pages. Does the ad’s promise match the first screen of the page. If not, the click is paid for, but the person didn’t find an answer.
Invalid traffic. The Report Library has an “Invalid traffic” report: it shows how many clicks antifraud filtered out. The money for them is returned to the balance automatically (Help). An important detail: Webvisor shows all visits, including those already filtered out. So “bots in Webvisor” doesn’t yet mean you paid for them. Cross-check against the reports in the “Direct” group in Metrica — only clicks that passed the check get there.
How can you tell the budget is being wasted without going into the settings?
The business owner can do part of the check themselves — with access to reports only. Five questions for the agency that break an imitation of work:
- What is the cost per lead for each campaign? Not the cost per click, the cost per lead.
- How many lines in the search queries report for the last month are about your service, and how many are not?
- Which YAN placements took the most money, and how many leads did they bring?
- Which goal is the strategy learning on, and does it match what you count as a lead?
- What was switched off in the last month, and why?
If there is no answer to the first question, there is no need to ask the rest. Without the cost per lead you can’t say whether the ads work or not.
And don’t put off the check. Data in Direct has a shelf life:
- the “Search queries” report stores data only for the last 180 days (Help);
- Yandex can check matching by autotargeting and semantic match for correctness only for the last 60 days (same source);
- conversions flagged as fraud — only for the last 30 days (Help).
If you have suspicions, export the data and contact support now, not “some time later”.
What access should you give for the audit, and are you risking your account?
Minimal. Direct has representatives with the “Read only” level: viewing campaign settings and statistics, with no access to the balance or payments (Help). A representative is added by the account’s chief representative: “Tools → Your representatives”. The login must be registered with Yandex but not yet used in Direct.
If an agency runs the account under its own agency account, you as the client can still create representatives for yourself (Help).
In Metrica, a similar level is called “View only”: the person sees the counter’s settings and statistics but cannot change goals or access. It is granted in “Settings → Access” (Metrica Help).
One rule is worth checking along the way: the account and the counter must be on your login. If they are on the agency’s login, when you part ways you risk being left without the campaign history and statistics.
What do you get at the end of the audit?
A good audit ends not with a “bad/good” verdict but with a list of actions. You should be left with:
- Spend map. Which campaigns, searches and placements bring leads and which only spend.
- Cost per lead for each campaign. Or an honest “it can’t be calculated” — with the reason: no goals, tagging gets lost, conversions are duplicated.
- A list of problems by priority. What is costing money right now and what can wait.
- Specific fixes. Which searches to add as negatives, which placements to block, which goal to switch the strategy to, which ads to rewrite.
- What lies outside the ads. The landing page, the form, how fast leads are answered — if the problem is there, it will be in the report too.
- An answer about the agency. Not “bad”, but what exactly was done wrong and whether it can be fixed without changing the team.
What an audit won’t give you is a guaranteed cost per lead. It shows where money is being lost now. The effect of the fixes shows only after the campaigns have run on the new settings, and how long that takes depends on the budget and the number of leads.
An audit of current campaigns is the first step of our work with Direct. We look at searches with no leads, empty placements and campaigns that duplicate each other. We work with read-only access, and the account stays yours. You can start with a free review: an hour of our time on your ads, website and analytics.