The report is written by an interested party
This is not an accusation, it is how things are built. The agency chooses which searches to show, what period to chart and which tasks to list. Even an honest specialist picks what looks better — the report also renews the contract.
So you should read it not as proof but as a claim. And check it the way you check any claim: ask about what isn’t in it.
Three elements that mislead
Rankings table
The most convincing and the most useless element. A ranking depends on the region, the device, the user’s history and the time of day — no two search results pages are the same. So a rankings table almost always describes the conditions under which it was taken, not your website. Three ways to make it green without a single useful action:
- Tracking searches where you were already first. Your own name, its typos, your office address. Technically these are rankings. In practice these are people who already know you.
- Tracking searches with no demand. “Buy a blue gear reducer in Zarechye cheap with delivery” — position one, zero impressions a month. The row looks exactly like a row for a real search.
- Showing “in the top 100” or “ranking dynamics”. Moving from position 87 to 54 is plus 33 points in the report and exactly zero visitors.
Traffic chart
Three things push it up that have nothing to do with SEO: seasonality, your own advertising and branded traffic — people who heard about you elsewhere and came to look up your address. Plus, occasionally, bots.
An honest chart is always split: non-branded search separately from branded, and compared year over year, not month over month, otherwise the season reads as the result of the work.
List of completed tasks
“40 pages optimized, 1,200 keywords collected, 12 texts written” is a report on effort spent, not on results. Forty pages, none of which answers a real search, are forty units of work and zero units of benefit.
Work is measured in results, not in volume. Agencies love the question “what did you do”. The question “what changed as a result” — less so.
Four lines that must be in the report
- Non-branded search traffic as a separate number, compared with the same month last year.
- The number of pages in search according to Yandex Webmaster — and how many there were a month ago.
- Inquiries from search: forms, calls, emails. Not visits.
- What is planned for next month, and why that in particular.
If these four lines are missing, the report is not about your business.
Five questions that break a bad report
Ask them one at a time, in writing, and ask for the answer as a number.
- How many monthly impressions do the searches in your rankings table get? “Let me check” is a fine answer. “That doesn’t matter, the ranking is what matters” is not.
- What share of search traffic is branded? If the agency doesn’t understand the question, it has never split the traffic.
- How many inquiries came from search last month and the month before? As a number, not “conversion is the website’s area of responsibility”.
- Show me access to Yandex Webmaster and Metrica. Not a report, the account itself. A refusal to give you access to your own data about your own website is an answer.
- What didn’t work over the last three months? Real work always has a part that failed. A report where everything worked describes not the work but a picture of it.
What you cannot demand
Guaranteed rankings. Nobody controls Yandex search results. Whoever guarantees a top 3 will either pick searches with no demand or fail to keep the promise. You can guarantee the scope of work and deadlines, not a position in someone else’s system.
Results within a month. Search traffic builds up over quarters. Demanding growth by the thirtieth of the month pushes the contractor straight towards imitation — it is the only way to meet the demand.
A report every week. The data changes slowly; weekly reporting creates noise and eats hours of preparation. A sensible rhythm is once a month, with only the technical side checked weekly: has indexing dropped off, has speed fallen.
We split it exactly this way ourselves: every week we keep the technical side of eighteen websites under control, while the conversation about results happens monthly. What this looks like in numbers is on the SEO case studies page.
If the answers didn’t satisfy you
Changing agencies is not the first step. The first step is to take your own measurement so you can talk in numbers: pages in search, non-branded searches, average ranking for them, inquiries. It is free and described in the article “the site is indexed, but there’s no traffic”.
With these four numbers, the conversation with your current agency changes completely. And if you do end up switching, you will know the starting point for the new one.