Design is the worst reason
The conversation about a rebuild almost always starts with “it looks like it’s from the 2000s”. The most visible sign and the weakest argument: fashion changes every three years, and the business doesn’t lose a single ruble from it directly. It is more useful to ask a different question: what has the website stopped being able to do that it needs to do today.
Six measurable signs
1. The website was built for desktop, but people come from their phones
Metrica, the “Technologies → Devices” report: the share of mobile users and, more importantly, the bounce rate on mobile compared with desktop. If mobile is more than half and its bounce rate is noticeably higher, you are losing your main audience at the door. This is not aesthetics, it is money.
2. It loads slowly on mobile internet
Don’t check from the office. Take your phone, turn off Wi-Fi, open the website. More than five seconds to the first screen is bad; more than eight, and half the people have already left.
Typical causes: photos uploaded at full camera resolution, and a dozen third-party scripts, half of them from services you stopped using long ago.
3. The content management system hasn’t been updated for a long time
A website on a popular CMS last updated three years ago is not a matter of convenience but of security: the known vulnerabilities of old versions are public, and they are scanned for automatically, not targeted. The sign the owner sees: “we don’t touch the site because something breaks after every update”.
4. The website doesn’t answer questions that came up later
Over a few years customers’ questions change: instalments, delivery, new payment methods, new concerns. If the structure is left over from the first version, the website answers the questions of customers from years ago.
Take the last five conversations, write down the customers’ questions and look for the answers on your website. How many did you find?
5. The contact options are behind the times
The phone number isn’t clickable on mobile. There is no messenger button, even though half of all inquiries come through messengers. The form asks for eight fields. There is no online payment, even though people ask for it. Each item is a small loss, but together they cost more than any redesign would fix.
6. The legal minimum is missing
A personal data processing policy, a consent checkbox on forms, company details in the footer. A website built a few years ago often has none of these simply because that is how things were done back then. More in the article on Metrica and personal data.
Measure not the age of the website but the gap between what it can do and how your customers behave now. Age in itself costs nothing.
Fix it or rebuild it
Write down the signs from the list that apply to you, ask the developer to estimate the fix for each one separately, add them up and compare with the price of a new website. Then there are three outcomes:
- If fixing costs less than a third of a new website, fix it. Rebuilding for the sake of rebuilding wipes out the accumulated search weight and history and gives you the same thing in return.
- If fixing costs more than half of a new one, rebuild. Otherwise you will keep paying extra for every next item.
- If the developer can’t estimate the fix, that is an answer too: working through the old code costs more than writing new code.
The most expensive redesign mistake
It is not about design or deadlines but about addresses. A rebuild almost always changes the structure — and if the old addresses return an error afterwards, search loses every page it knew, and traffic built up over years is wiped out in a few weeks.
What to demand in writing:
- Export the list of all pages of the old website before work starts — from Yandex Webmaster, the “Pages in search” section.
- Make a redirect map: every old address → the new one.
- Set up permanent redirects from the old addresses to the new ones.
- Don’t change the Metrica counter. The same counter number keeps the whole history; a new one starts from zero, and you will have nothing to compare “before and after” with.
- After launch, check in Yandex Webmaster that pages haven’t dropped out of the index and that old addresses lead where they should.
This is the only part of a redesign that can cost more than the redesign itself. How we handle it is on the search and SEO page.
A half-hour check
- Metrica → devices: the share of mobile users and their bounce rate separately.
- Phone, mobile internet, stopwatch: how long until the first screen.
- CMS version and date of the last update — a question for the developer.
- The last five conversations: how many questions the website answers.
- From a phone: is the phone number clickable, is there a messenger button, how many fields are in the form.
- Footer: policy, consent on forms, company details.
Six answers turn “time to update” into a list of two or three specific jobs — and it often turns out that you don’t need a new website at all.
What a redesign won’t do
It won’t raise conversion by itself. Prettier doesn’t mean clearer. Conversion is raised by prices on the pages, answers to objections and working forms, not by changing fonts.
It won’t bring traffic. A new website with no work on traffic sources will get as many visitors as the old one — at best.
It won’t remove the need for maintenance. In three years the new website will be old by the same six signs. The only difference is whether someone looks after it.